Gianluigi Donnarumma has gone from Paris Saint-Germain’s crown jewel to surplus at Luis Enrique’s disposal in a matter of months. The arrival of Lille’s Lucas Chevalier, prized for his ball-playing ability, immediately nudged Donnarumma down the pecking order. Enrique has made it clear he won’t be his first-choice goalkeeper next season and even omitted him from the UEFA Super Cup squad.
PSG now boast five senior keepers—Donnarumma, Chevalier, Renato Marín, Arnau Tenas and Matvey Safonov—making Donnarumma’s path back into the XI almost impossible. With one year left on his deal and no extension in sight, Paris prefer selling this summer rather than losing him for free in 2026.
Chelsea vs. Manchester United: Who’s More Likely to Sign Him?
| Criteria | Chelsea | Manchester United |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer Approach | Early inquiries to PSG; willing to replace Robert Sánchez | Ongoing talks but needs to offload Onana or Bayindir first |
| Financial Flexibility | Backed by consortium’s deep pockets; fewer mandatory sales | Constrained by FFP; must fund transfer via player sales |
| Squad Status | Seeking a long-term No. 1; clear roster spot | Europe qualification uncertain; juggling multiple keepers |
| Competitive Appeal | Likely Champions League football; rebuild under new ownership | No European football this season; appeal may be lower |
| Estimated Fee | €20 – 30 million PSG asking price | Comparable, but confined by internal budget restrictions |
On balance, Chelsea currently have the clearer runway. They’ve inquired directly, have the funds to meet PSG’s €20 – 30 million valuation and a defined vacancy between the posts. Manchester United remain interested, but FFP and the need to offload existing goalkeepers give Chelsea the edge in the race.
What Donnarumma Brings and How He Improves the Side
- Shot-Stopping Excellence
Exceptional reflexes and one-on-one prowess, proven by his Champions League-winning exploits with PSG. - Command of the Area
Vocal and authoritative in marshaling the back line, boosting defensive organization on set pieces and crosses. - Big-Game Temperament
Composure under pressure, evidenced by his Yashin Trophy nomination and consistent performances on Europe’s biggest stages. - Ball Distribution
While not as polished as Chevalier, he offers reliable short passes and accurate goal kicks, fitting a coach who still prioritizes keeper involvement in build-up. - Leadership and Experience
Despite his youth, he’s captained Italy to Euro glory and won multiple domestic trophies, bringing winning mentality to a squad in transition.
Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths
- Lightning-quick reflexes and shot-stopping
- Excellent penalty-saving record
- Strong organizational skills in the box
- Proven track record on the biggest stages
Weaknesses
- Distribution under intense pressing can lack zip
- Has had occasional concentration lapses in high-tempo leagues
- Contract-negotiation standoff could signal off-field distractions
Looking beyond Chelsea and United, Manchester City, Galatasaray and even Saudi Pro League contenders have checked in on Donnarumma. His next decision will weigh immediate game-time, European competition and project stability.
